Abstract
Industry-Based Certifications (IBCs) have emerged as a significant element of the Career and Technical Education (CTE) accountability models for Texas high schools, especially within the College, Career, and Military Readiness (CCMR) framework. Nevertheless, concerns have grown about the labor-market worth, equity considerations, and accountability use of low-value certifications. In this study, the patterns of IBC use across the state were evaluated and their associations with CTE programming, accountability policy, and student readiness indicators were examined. The study was based on the Improvement Science framework; it had a quantitative descriptive and longitudinal research design that was conducted with analysis conducted in JASP and Python. The dataset was a combination of statewide IBC master records, district accountability datasets, CCMR indicators, regional certification counts, and program-level workforce pathway data from 2022-2025. The results showed that the value of approved certifications is unevenly distributed across the statewide IBC list. Among the 474 current certifications on the 2025–2030 accountability list, Tier 1 credentials, those most strongly aligned with high-wage, high demand occupations constituted only 4.9% (n = 23), while Tier 2 credentials dominated at 73.6% (n = 349) and Tier 3 accounted for 21.5% (n = 102). A chi-square goodness-of-fit test confirmed that this distribution departs significantly from uniformity, χ² (2, N = 474) = 2 366.09, p < .001, indicating constrained access to the most valuable credentials. Analysis of multi-cycle list data showed that certification sunsetting is a recurring feature of the system: comparable cohorts of roughly 60 certifications were phased out at successive cycle transitions, while the approved list expanded substantially across cycles, from 207 certifications (2019-2022) to 294 (2022-2024) to 474 (2025-2030). Persistent demographic inequalities were also evident. Non-economically disadvantaged students significantly outperformed economically disadvantaged students within the same districts (mean gap = .164, t(921) = 36.40, p < .001, Cohen’s dₖ = 1.20, a very large effect, and special education students performed lowest of all (dₖ = 1.52 relative to economically disadvantaged peers). Regional variation was also significant, F(19, 999) = 3.64, p < .001, η² = .065. A composite equity-adjusted index and a Pareto decomposition across the 20 regions showed that regional standing reorders substantially once the evenness of readiness is weighed alongside its level, and that each region’s readiness shortfall concentrates in roughly three student groups. A pathway-substitution analysis further showed that the college-ready route dominates for every student group in every region and that access to the certification pathway is lowest for the same groups that trail on college readiness. Although the study originated as an examination of credential value, equity in access to readiness pathways emerged as its most significant system-level concern: the subgroup disparities were the largest and most statistically robust effects observed and were stable across cohorts. Taken together, the findings indicate that Texas CTE accountability systems may benefit from weighing credential value and equitable access alongside certification counts rather than treating all certifications as equivalent. Consistent with the study’s diagnostic, non-causal design, these results are interpreted as system-level patterns rather than demonstrated causal effects. Policy implications to consider include refining IBC tiering, monitoring subgroup access to high-value pathways, and supporting districts through 3 accountability transitions.
Date of publication
Fall 11-5-2026
Document Type
Dissertation
Language
english
Persistent identifier
http://hdl.handle.net/10950/5217
Recommended Citation
Rios, Antonio Jr, "A STATEWIDE EVALUATION OF LOW-VALUE IBC USAGE AND ITS IMPLICATIONS FOR CTE PROGRAMMING" (2026). Education Theses and Dissertations. Paper 54.
http://hdl.handle.net/10950/5217